Blank white horizontal strip on a light gray background

Our STory

About Us

Creekstone Benefits is dedicated to providing personalized, client-first guidance by simplifying complex coverage options and delivering tailored benefits strategies for individuals, families, and businesses.

Insurance can be complicated, but our job is to make it clear. At Creekstone Benefits, we take the time to walk you through your options, answer your questions, and ensure you feel confident every step of the way. With more than two decades of experience, our team provides thoughtful, one-on-one support for Medicare, individual health plans, supplemental coverage, and employee benefits. As an independent, woman-owned agency, we focus on what’s best for you—not a single insurance company.

We Believe In Educating, Not Selling

Our Team of Specialists

Headshot of a smiling person wearing pink glasses, a black blazer, and white top on a white background

Tiffany Geiger

President and founder

More About Tiffany
Smiling person in glasses and a dark blue sweater on a white background

Bud Fassnacht

Benefits Specialist

More About Bud
Woman with glasses smiling in a dark sweater against a white background
Portrait of a smiling person with gray hair, glasses, and a black-and-white sweater on a white background

Penny Hall

Client Service Specialist

More About Penny

Service Area

We Serve People Across Ohio, Indiana, Florida, and Michigan

In Central Ohio, Creekstone Benefits specializes in the following counties:  Licking, Franklin, Muskingum, Morrow, Knox, Ross, Tuscarawas, Pickaway, Marion, Logan, Hocking, Portage, Coshocton, Mongomery, Hamilton, Athens.  Cities: Columbus, Newark, Alexandria, Johnstown. Mt Vernon, Cincinnati, Dayton, Lancaster, Zanesville, Marion, Fredericktown, Akron, Canton, Granville, Sunbury, Heath, New Albany, Ravenna, Steubenville, Chillicothe, New Philadelphia, Gahanna, Groveport, Zanesville, Etna, Pickerington, New Concord, Frazeysburg.

Wooded creek with calm brown water and green trees along the banks

Licensed in these states: Ohio • Indiana • Florida • Michigan

Creekstone Benefits is a proud member of:

NABIP logo with blue and teal circular icon and tagline “Shaping the future of healthcare”
Granville Area Chamber of Commerce logo in blue text and stylized swirl icon
Licking County Chamber of Commerce logo in blue with tagline “Building Leaders. Growing Community.”
Johnstown Chamber of Commerce circular logo with red text and a black-and-white street scene
Clintonville Main Business Association logo with a storefront under a striped awning

Summary of SERVICES

What We Offer

MEDICARE

Health Insurance

Group Benefits

Supplemental Insurance

Dental & Vision Insurance

We can help you navigate insurance!

Call us at (740) 967-0210 or contact us for your free quote.